I have watched this a couple times because I like DC TV. I have the DVD collection of Justice League Unlimited, Young Justice, and Constantine (which is like the worst case of story-interruptus ever!). I am not as invested in the CW line up, but I have enjoyed them. (Legends is very cool. Once they found their niche as “the comedy team,” it’s been great.)
It’s “the rule.” Marvel rocks the big screen, DC rocks the small screen (especially productions under Bruce Timm).
So beyond Superman (who frankly I think it still riding the coattails of the 1970’s films with Christopher Reeve), Batman, and now Wonder Woman, why has DC not been able to pull it together on the big screen?
Justice League had three fully established characters. The “Big Three” in fact: Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman.
As much as people hate Ben Affleck, I thought he did a good job. Not Christian Bale great, but good. I think he was the Batman who worked for a team film because I can’t see Christian Bale’s Batman teaming up with anybody, let alone spearheading forming a team
Of course Gal Godot is awesome-sauce as WW. She nailed the character from day one.
Henry Cavill is o.k. as Superman. It’s hard for me to judge because I’ve never been a big Superman fan. I do like that in the Cavill films, writers focused more on Superman’s human side than alien. When he was resurrected, it was not WW’s appeals to “Kal El, Last Son of Krypton” that brought him back to himself. It was the reminders of his life as a human being. (Which the comic book WW would have got that, but I’m willing to give movie WW a pass because she’s demi-goddess raised in a society that knew Gods and Goddesses, so it’s feel natural for her to appeal to the “god” first before the man.)
Jason Momoa threw a fully realized and engaging Aquaman up there with zero backstory or prep. He was awesome. If you were not invested in his character you were at least entertained.
So four out of five.
Grant Gustin *is* the Flash (on TV) and recasting him for the film felt wrong. It was hard to get over that. Ezra Miller did well with the material he was given, but they wrote him too young to play with the big kids. By the time the Flash joined the League, he was a fully realized hero in his own right. Yes, he’s a goofball, but he’s no n00b. And I think writing him a bit older and more experienced would have worked better. (And the funny thing is when they first introduced him, they hinted he was more experienced than that with “I’m fluent in sign language. Gorilla sign language,” which is a fanservice reference to Grodd, who is in the Flash rogue’s gallery.)
Cyborg. I don’t know why there is this push to make him be a founding member of the Justice League (GL and Hawkgirl are the other two founding members) when the guy was a Teen Titan long after the Justice League was founded. I guess for the film’s sake, he was needed for the Apocalypse tech (Mother Boxes). And he had his moments when he was not being Broody McAngsty.
The story was solid. I would not say fantastic: “Big alien invasion brings superheroes together to for team” is a classic trope. It’s a “pilot” film and those are always a little weak. That is was a little more complex than aliens pouring out of the sky because an Asgardian was getting his snit on was nice.
So why doesn’t it have the punch the first Avengers film did?
Character development, yeah. The Avengers had more. Even the Black Widow, who did not have her own film, was more developed than Aquaman, Flash or Cyborg.
But I think where the Avengers really surged ahead is Loki was a much more interesting villain who was fun to watch. Steppenwolf was more of mechanism where Loki brought all his attitude and personal baggage and Hiddleston rocked it.
“Your protagonist is only as good and interesting as your antagonist.” – Master Class in Writing from Chris Claremont. (Actually he said it in an interview decades ago about how he changed the X-Men and their “world” when he took over in 1974, but MAN is it so true.)
Another thing struck me re-watching Justice League last night, and you’re going to laugh or think I’m nuts, but music.
As I observed a long time ago, soundtrack can make or break a film. I don’t think Gladiator would have been as successful as it was without Zimmer’s soundtrack pulling at our heartstrings.
And the only iconic musical theme DC has produced that gets our blood pumping is Wonder Woman’s.
(And to be frank, she has the best fight choreography too.)
For the Justice League, can anyone remember the music at all?
And it’s Danny Elfman!?! How does Danny Elfman turn out a forgettable theme? But he did.
Whereas The Avengers theme:
Face it, you just got teeny rush, didn’t you? You totally saw Cap or Tony, didn’t you?
And they slip it into every single MCU film. It maybe five seconds of it, but it’s in every single film which of course helps to subconsciously establish universe continuity.
See. Music matters.